Why Won’t My Brisket Get Tender?

Few things are more frustrating than a brisket that looks done but still won’t get tender.

If your brisket feels tight, chewy or resistant to the probe, it means the collagen hasn’t fully broken down yet. Tender brisket isn’t about just hitting a specific temperature. It’s about giving the meat enough time and heat to relax.

See the full Brisket Troubleshooting Guide

PRO TIP: For a moist brisket every time, follow all of the steps in my no-fail brisket recipe. 

What Tender Brisket Should Feel Like

A tender brisket doesn’t just look good. It feels different.

When brisket is tender:

• A probe slides in with little to no resistance
• The flat feels relaxed, not tight
• Slices bend easily and pull apart with minimal effort

If the probe meets resistance, the brisket is not tender yet, even if the thermometer says it is.

The Most Common Reason Brisket Won’t Get Tender

The most common reason brisket won’t get tender is simple.

It hasn’t cooked long enough.

Brisket is a tough cut loaded with connective tissue. That collagen only breaks down after extended time at higher internal temperatures. Until that happens, the meat stays firm.

This is why brisket can stall at a temperature and feel stuck, even though it’s still cooking internally.

Why Temperature Alone Can Be Misleading

Many cooks expect brisket to become tender at a specific temperature, often around 203F.

In reality:

• Some briskets are tender at lower temperatures
• Others don’t get tender until they push past 205F or higher

Tenderness depends on:

• Brisket size and thickness
• Fat content and grade
• Pit temperature
• How the brisket was wrapped and rested

Temperature is a guide, not the finish line.

Why the Flat Feels Tougher Than the Point

It’s common for the flat to stay firm while the point feels tender.

That’s because:

• The flat is leaner and contains less fat
• The point has more marbling

Always probe multiple spots. If the flat isn’t tender, the brisket needs more time, even if the point feels ready.

PRO TIP: If you're cooking a higher-grade brisket, you need to make sure the fat in the point fully renders. Otherwise, when it starts to cool it will become chewy. This is where relying on both temperature and probe tenderness will make you an all star.

Can You Make a Tough Brisket Tender?

Yes, in most cases.

If the brisket is still intact and warm:

• Wrap it tightly in foil or butcher paper
• Return it to the smoker or oven at 250F to 275F
• Continue cooking until it becomes probe tender

Adding time and steady heat allows the collagen to finish breaking down.

What If the Brisket Is Already Rested or Sliced?

If the brisket has rested but is still tough, you can often return it to heat.

If it has already been sliced, options are more limited, but gentle reheating with added moisture can still improve texture.

The key is patience. Tough brisket almost always means unfinished brisket.

How to Prevent Tough Brisket Next Time

To avoid brisket that won’t get tender:

• Wrap your brisket to push through the stall
• Cook at a slightly higher temperature
• Cook until probe tender
• Rest the brisket properly before slicing

Brisket Guides

This BBQ Tip is part of my Ultimate Brisket Guide, which breaks down every step from anatomy to trimming to cooking.

Explore more brisket fundamentals:

For a full overview:

My Go-To Brisket Rub for Building Flavor and Bark

I use Girls Can Grill Brisket Rub on all of my briskets. This blend layers salt, pepper, garlic and savory spices to highlight the natural beef flavor while helping the bark develop evenly.