Alternatives To Wrapping Brisket – Girls Can Grill

If you’re looking for alternatives to wrapping brisket, these three methods give you options depending on bark, moisture and cook time.

Most pitmasters wrap brisket at some point during the cook, but wrapping isn’t your only option.

Depending on your goals, bark, moisture, cook time or simplicity, there are three main alternatives: the pan method, the boat method and the classic no-wrap cook.

This guide is part of my Ultimate Brisket Guide.

Pan Method (a.k.a. “Foil Pan + Cover”)

The pan method is one of the most common alternatives to traditional wrapping. It’s essentially a braise-style alternative to wrapping brisket, perfect for moisture retention.

Place the brisket into a disposable aluminum pan, add a mop or broth, and cover the top tightly with foil.

This is a favorite among competitive pitmasters cooking hot and fast. At higher temperatures, moisture evaporates quickly, and the pan helps capture and recycle that moisture.

Pros:

• Extremely moist, tender brisket
• Great for hot-and-fast cooks
• Helps protect the flat from drying out

Cons:

• Least bark development
• Produces more of a braised texture
• Not ideal if you want a dark, crunchy crust

PRO TIP: When I'm cooking hot and fast in competitions, I almost always use the pan method. When I’m cooking low and slow at home, I prefer butcher paper or foil.

Boat Method (Partial Wrap)

The boat method sits between fully wrapping and not wrapping at all. You create a “boat” out of foil or butcher paper, shaping it around the bottom and sides of the brisket while leaving the top completely exposed.

The goal is simple: protect the bottom of the brisket from drying out while allowing the top to continue forming bark without steaming.

Pros:

• Best bark of any semi-wrapped method
• Protects the flat
• Allows smoke and airflow to hit the top of the brisket
• Doesn’t trap steam like traditional wrapping

Cons:

• Slower cook time than a full wrap with foil or paper
• Won’t retain as much moisture as a full wrap
• Pan drippings won’t braise the meat

This method has become incredibly popular with backyard pitmasters using offsets or pellet grills because it strikes a great balance between moisture control and bark quality.

No-Wrap (Naked Brisket)

The no-wrap method is the most old-school approach and the simplest: just leave the brisket unwrapped the entire cook.

This produces the darkest, crunchiest bark, but also the longest cook time because you have to ride through the stall.

Pros:

• Maximum bark formation
• Deepest smoke flavor
• Best airflow for a crusty exterior

Cons:

• Longest stall
• Longest total cook time
• Higher chance of drying out the flat
• Requires close fire management

Choose this method when bark is your #1 priority and time isn’t a concern. It works best to cook at lower temperatures, so you don’t dry out the meat.

Which Alternative Method Should You Choose?

Choose the Pan Method if:

• You’re cooking hot and fast
• Moisture is the priority
• You’re using lean brisket grades

Choose the Boat Method if:

• You want great bark but need some moisture protection
• You’re cooking at moderate temps
• You like a hybrid between wrapping and no wrapping

Choose No-Wrap if:

• Bark is everything
• You’re cooking on an offset
• You have plenty of time
• You’re after an old-school brisket profile

Comparison Chart: Alternative Brisket Methods

Brisket Guides

This BBQ Tip is part of my Ultimate Brisket Guide, which breaks down every step from anatomy to trimming to cooking.

Explore more brisket fundamentals:

For a full overview:

My Go-To Brisket Rub for Building Flavor and Bark

I use Girls Can Grill Brisket Rub on all of my briskets. This blend layers salt, pepper, garlic and savory spices to highlight the natural beef flavor while helping the bark develop evenly.